The Great Musical Displacement: Artistry vs. Algorithm 

The contemporary pricing structure for tickets to mainstream concert tours has reached a level that can only be described as profoundly exclusionary. One might argue this is a logical consequence of the increasingly grandiose, theatrical spectacles that now accompany these global tours. It is a curious observation, however, that these elaborate productions often appear to either eclipse the core talent of the featured artist or, conversely, serve to obscure certain artistic limitations.

This climate is strikingly reminiscent of a specific historical pivot, namely the late 1970s, wherein the punk movement arose as a direct rebuttal to the perceived excesses of progressive and arena rock. One detects a similar, albeit more diffuse, punk-esque sentiment today—a rebellion against the pervasive overproduction in modern music. Let us be perfectly clear: this analogy is drawn purely in spirit. While we champion the ethos of artistic authenticity, we do not endorse the deliberate musical primitivism that characterized much of the punk genre. Our appreciation remains firmly with the demonstrated excellence found in jazz, classical, and certain quarters of the contemporary pop landscape, where musical proficiency is paramount.

Furthermore, the increasing reliance on digital manipulation, automated plugins, and artificial intelligence has, in our view, significantly degraded the listening experience. The opportunity to witness the unadulterated skill and spontaneous creativity of a human musician is being systematically eroded. We remain unconvinced by appeals to so-called “new sonic textures,” particularly when such innovations are deployed by those seemingly lacking a foundational understanding of musical theory and practice.

Concurrently, the traditional recording industry has manifestly failed to adapt and, for all practical purposes, exists now only in a moribund state. One can reasonably project a near future in which concert venues are populated not by living artists, but by performances generated and executed by artificial intelligence.

It is, from our perspective, a profoundly disheartening trajectory to witness: the gradual displacement of the genuine musician, the authentic vocalist, and the skilled performer by a fabricated, artificial replica. The diminution of human artistry in favor of algorithmic convenience is a cultural loss we find deeply lamentable.


Discover more from Glamour & Truth: 95 Years in Showbiz

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading